Joint Custody vs. Sole Custody
 -
My Blog

Joint Custody vs. Sole Custody


What is the difference between joint and sole custody?

Custody is a legal term and refers to whom, whether parent(s) guardian, state, or otherwise, has the legal ability to make decisions on behalf of the child(ren). Custody is not exactly the same as where the kids live. The details of where the kids will spend their time, which schools they will attend, which churches if any they will attend, extracurricular activities etc. are governed by the parenting plan. Generally speaking, custody can be divided into two broad categories: joint custody and sole custody.

Joint custody means that both parents share in the decision-making and parenting of the children. Both parents are to be included in school activities, both parents are to be afforded quality time with their children. This by no means 50-50 timesharing or even any percentage of custodianship. Joint custody simply means joint decision-making.

Sole legal custody means only one parent has legal authority and responsibility for the child. The other parent may have ample visitation but has no legal ability to make decisions on the child’s behalf. Sole legal custody is not, therefore, the same as sole physical custody. Nevertheless sole legal custody is oftentimes challenging to get and in most cases is not likely in the child’s best interest.

In most cases, sole legal custody is awarded to one parent over another when there’s sexual and/or physical or emotional abuse involved. Barring something like that, sole legal custody is difficult to get. That however is not the same as being awarded sole physical custody while both parents are awarded joint legal custody.

Judges tend to also tailor legal and physical custody distinctions to the particular case. Sometimes they craft “special joint custody” or “modified joint custody” which can cause some confusion.

That being said, each state has its own rules and laws defining custody. The reader is cautioned to research the state statutes applicable to the reader’s particular jurisdiction.

In New Mexico, our laws favor joint custody. This point is huge! Almost every other jurisdiction in the United States does not. (Readers living in other states must research this point within the context of their particular state.) As you read the law, I want you to pay particular attention to first the opening presumption regarding joint custody but then look at the detail in terms of what the Courts expect in terms of the parenting plan. In other words, this is a very wide encompassing statute. Here’s the law:

40-4-9.1 NMSA 1978. Joint custody; standards for determination; parenting plan.

A. There shall be a presumption that joint custody is in the best interests of a child in an initial custody determination. An award of joint custody does not imply an equal division of financial responsibility for the child. Joint custody shall not be awarded as a substitute for an existing custody arrangement unless there has been a substantial and material change in circumstances since the entry of the prior custody order or decree, which change affects the welfare of the child such that joint custody is presently in the best interests of the child. With respect to any proceeding in which it is proposed that joint custody be terminated, the court shall not terminate joint custody unless there has been a substantial and material change in circumstances affecting the welfare of the child, since entry of the joint custody order, such that joint custody is no longer in the best interests of the child.

B. In determining whether a joint custody order is in the best interests of the child, in addition to the factors provided in Section 40-4-9 NMSA 1978, the court shall consider the following factors:

(1) whether the child has established a close relationship with each parent;

(2) whether each parent is capable of providing adequate care for the child throughout each period of responsibility, including arranging for the child's care by others as needed;

(3) whether each parent is willing to accept all responsibilities of parenting, including a willingness to accept care of the child at specified times and to relinquish care to the other parent at specified times;

(4) whether the child can best maintain and strengthen a relationship with both parents through predictable, frequent contact and whether the child's development will profit from such involvement and influence from both parents;

(5) whether each parent is able to allow the other to provide care without intrusion, that is, to respect the other's parental rights and responsibilities and right to privacy;

(6) the suitability of a parenting plan for the implementation of joint custody, preferably, although not necessarily, one arrived at through parental agreement;

(7) geographic distance between the parents' residences;

(8) willingness or ability of the parents to communicate, cooperate or agree on issues regarding the child's needs; and

(9) whether a judicial adjudication has been made in a prior or the present proceeding that either parent or other person seeking custody has engaged in one or more acts of domestic abuse against the child, a parent of the child or other household member. If a determination is made that domestic abuse has occurred, the court shall set forth findings that the custody or visitation ordered by the court adequately protects the child, the abused parent or other household member.

C. In any proceeding in which the custody of a child is at issue, the court shall not prefer one parent as a custodian solely because of gender.

D. In any case in which the parents agree to a form of custody, the court should award custody consistent with the agreement unless the court determines that such agreement is not in the best interests of the child.

E. In making an order of joint custody, the court may specify the circumstances, if any, under which the consent of both legal custodians is required to be obtained in order to exercise legal control of the child and the consequences of the failure to obtain mutual consent.

F. When joint custody is awarded, the court shall approve a parenting plan for the implementation of the prospective custody arrangement prior to the award of joint custody. The parenting plan shall include a division of a child's time and care into periods of responsibility for each parent. It may also include:

(1) statements regarding the child's religion, education, child care, recreational activities and medical and dental care;

(2) designation of specific decision-making responsibilities;

(3) methods of communicating information about the child, transporting the child, exchanging care for the child and maintaining telephone and mail contact between parent and child;

(4) procedures for future decision making, including procedures for dispute resolution; and

(5) other statements regarding the welfare of the child or designed to clarify and facilitate parenting under joint custody arrangements.

In a case where joint custody is not agreed to or necessary aspects of the parenting plan are contested, the parties shall each submit parenting plans. The court may accept the plan proposed by either party or it may combine or revise these plans as it deems necessary in the child's best interests. The time of filing of parenting plans shall be set by local rule. A plan adopted by the court shall be entered as an order of the court.

G. Where custody is contested, the court shall refer that issue to mediation if feasible. The court may also use auxiliary services such as professional evaluation by application of Rule 706 [Rule 11-706 NMRA] of the New Mexico Rules of Evidence or Rule 53 [Rule 1-053 NMRA] of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts.

H. Notwithstanding any other provisions of law, access to records and information pertaining to a minor child, including medical, dental and school records, shall not be denied to a parent because that parent is not the child's physical custodial parent or because that parent is not a joint custodial parent.

I. Whenever a request for joint custody is granted or denied, the court shall state in its decision its basis for granting or denying the request for joint custody. A statement that joint custody is or is not in the best interests of the child is not sufficient to meet the requirements of this subsection.

J. An award of joint custody means that:

(1) each parent shall have significant, well-defined periods of responsibility for the child;

(2) each parent shall have, and be allowed and expected to carry out, responsibility for the child's financial, physical, emotional and developmental needs during that parent's periods of responsibility;

(3) the parents shall consult with each other on major decisions involving the child before implementing those decisions; that is, neither parent shall make a decision or take an action which results in a major change in a child's life until the matter has been discussed with the other parent and the parents agree. If the parents, after discussion, cannot agree and if one parent wishes to effect a major change while the other does not wish the major change to occur, then no change shall occur until the issue has been resolved as provided in this subsection;

(4) the following guidelines apply to major changes in a child's life:

(a) if either parent plans to change his home city or state of residence, he shall provide to the other parent thirty days' notice in writing stating the date and destination of move;

(b) the religious denomination and religious activities, or lack thereof, which were being practiced during the marriage should not be changed unless the parties agree or it has been otherwise resolved as provided in this subsection;

(c) both parents shall have access to school records, teachers and activities. The type of education, public or private, which was in place during the marriage should continue, whenever possible, and school districts should not be changed unless the parties agree or it has been otherwise resolved as provided in this subsection;

(d) both parents shall have access to medical and dental treatment providers and records. Each parent has authority to make emergency medical decisions. Neither parent may contract for major elective medical or dental treatment unless both parents agree or it has been otherwise resolved as provided in this subsection; and

(e) both parents may attend the child's public activities and both parents should know the necessary schedules. Whatever recreational activities the child participated in during the marriage should continue with the child's agreement, regardless of which of the parents has physical custody. Also, neither parent may enroll the child in a new recreational activity unless the parties agree or it has been otherwise resolved as provided in this subsection; and

(5) decisions regarding major changes in a child's life may be decided by:

(a) agreement between the joint custodial parents;

(b) requiring that the parents seek family counseling, conciliation or mediation service to assist in resolving their differences;

(c) agreement by the parents to submit the dispute to binding arbitration;

(d) allocating ultimate responsibility for a particular major decision area to one legal custodian;

(e) terminating joint custody and awarding sole custody to one person;

(f) reference to a master pursuant to Rule 53 [Rule 1-053 NMRA] of the Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts; or

(g) the district court.

K. When any person other than a natural or adoptive parent seeks custody of a child, no such person shall be awarded custody absent a showing of unfitness of the natural or adoptive parent.

L. As used in this section:

(1) "child" means a person under the age of eighteen;

(2) "custody" means the authority and responsibility to make major decisions in a child's best interests in the areas of residence, medical and dental treatment, education or child care, religion and recreation;

(3) "domestic abuse" means any incident by a household member against another household member resulting in:

(a) physical harm;

(b) severe emotional distress;

(c) a threat causing imminent fear of physical harm by any household member;

(d) criminal trespass;

(e) criminal damage to property;

(f) stalking or aggravated stalking, as provided in Sections 30-3A-3 and 30-3A-3.1 NMSA 1978; or

(g) harassment, as provided in Section 30-3A-2 NMSA 1978;

(4) "joint custody" means an order of the court awarding custody of a child to two parents. Joint custody does not imply an equal division of the child's time between the parents or an equal division of financial responsibility for the child;

(5) "parent" means a natural parent, adoptive parent or person who is acting as a parent who has or shares legal custody of a child or who claims a right to have or share legal custody;

(6) "parenting plan" means a document submitted for approval of the court setting forth the responsibilities of each parent individually and the parents jointly in a joint custody arrangement;

(7) "period of responsibility" means a specified period of time during which a parent is responsible for providing for a child's physical, developmental and emotional needs, including the decision making required in daily living. Specified periods of responsibility shall not be changed in an instance or more permanently except by the methods of decision making described under Subsection L [sic] of this section;

(8) "sole custody" means an order of the court awarding custody of a child to one parent; and

(9) "visitation" means a period of time available to a noncustodial parent, under a sole custody arrangement, during which a child resides with or is under the care and control of the noncustodial parent.

Disclaimer: These codes may not be the most recent version.

Many states have similar statutes but you must find out for yourself!

 


13 Comments to Joint Custody vs. Sole Custody:

Comments RSS
Online essay on Wednesday, June 22, 2016 9:36 PM
Your blog is very useful and provides tremendous facts. Keep up the good work. Thank you!
Reply to comment
 
mike on Monday, July 25, 2016 11:42 PM
windows key for windows 10 ultimate for windows for ultimate key , windows 10 enterprise genuine key download , microsoft outlook 2010 product keys , windows 10 professional , buy windows 10 key , oB{LZdlS


Anonymous on Friday, December 02, 2016 9:00 PM
dg
Reply to comment


Creative Man on Monday, July 10, 2017 7:15 AM
Great Article! It is really informative and innovative. Share also this web site.
Reply to comment


Onefinelawyer on Friday, August 04, 2017 4:47 AM
Wow!! This is something I ‘ve been searching for for a while.I’m thankful to you for writing this article.
Reply to comment


essays writing services on Monday, April 23, 2018 3:34 AM
This really informative thing that you shared about the difference between two things according to the law. I also looking for much other law matter same like that posted for unknown persons those who have no idea about it.
Reply to comment


free sudoku on Tuesday, July 03, 2018 9:47 PM
Online games are very nice and amazing to play free of cost without download if you are interested to play so click on our site and do enjoy.
Reply to comment


buy IWC Replica Watches on Saturday, July 14, 2018 1:03 PM
Going to graduate school was a positive decision for me.
Reply to comment


AAA Replica Watches on Sunday, July 15, 2018 8:11 PM
Also I like the conclusions made on this topic like The Internet which is really very informative.keep it up
Reply to comment


loemrntdherid1 on Sunday, August 05, 2018 7:58 PM
I really liked your article. Keep up the good work.
Reply to comment


Jahon on Wednesday, August 08, 2018 1:14 AM
I really appreciate from this blog. You have to explain each and every point very clearly. Thanks for sharing this information. rubber roofing Company in uk
Reply to comment


Renu Das on Wednesday, August 08, 2018 4:03 AM
Renu Das Kolkata Escorts Services has gorgeous females provides Independent Escorts Service in Kolkata call girls at 100% satisfaction with VIP models. Provided Kolkata escorts at our agency are professional in nature and are eager to serve you at your place.
Reply to comment


Priya on Wednesday, August 08, 2018 4:06 AM
Renu Das Kolkata Escorts Services has gorgeous females provides Independent Escorts Service in Kolkata call girls at 100% satisfaction with VIP models. Provided Kolkata escorts at our agency are professional in nature and are eager to serve you at your place. Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escort Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Kolkata Escorts Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Gurgaon Escorts Delhi Escorts Call girls in Kolkata Kolkata Escort Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escort Gurgaon Escorts Escorts in Gurgaon Escorts Service in Gurgaon Female Escorts in Gurgaon Independent Escorts in Gurgaon Delhi Escorts Delhi Escorts Escorts in Delhi Escorts Service in Delhi Female Escorts in Delhi Independent Escorts in Delhi Gurgaon Escorts Escorts in Gurgaon Escorts Service Female Escorts in Gurgaon Independent Escorts in Gurgaon Delhi Escorts Delhi Escorts Call Girls in Kolkata Escorts in Kolkata Escorts Service in Kolkata Female Escorts in Kolkata Independent Escorts in Kolkata Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Rajarhat Escorts Escorts in Rajarhat Escorts Service in Rajarhat Female Escorts in Rajarhat Independent Escorts in Rajarhat Rajarhat Escorts Howrah Escorts Escorts in Howrah Escorts Service in Howrah Female Escorts in Howrah Independent Escorts in Howrah Sealdah Escorts Escorts in Sealdah Escorts Service in Sealdah Female Escorts in Sealdah Independent Escorts in Sealdah Newtown Escorts Escorts in Newtown Escorts Service in Newtown Female Escorts in Newtown Independent Escorts in Newtown Belgachia Escorts Escorts in Belgachia Escorts Service in Belgachia Female Escorts in Belgachia Independent Escorts in Belgachia Ultadanga Escorts Escorts in Ultadanga Escorts Service in Ultadanga Female Escorts in Ultadanga Independent Escorts in Ultadanga Barrackpur Escorts Escorts in Barrackpur Escorts Service in Barrackpur Female Escorts in Barrackpur Independent Escorts in Barrackpur Kalighat Escorts Escorts in Kalighat Escorts Service in Kalighat Female Escorts in Kalighat Independent Escorts in Kalighat Sonarpur Escorts Escorts in Sonarpur Escorts Service in Sonarpur Female Escorts in Sonarpur Independent Escorts in Sonarpur Kalyani Escorts Escorts in Kalyani Escorts Service in Kalyani Female Escorts in Kalyani Independent Escorts in Kalyani Ballygunge Escorts Escorts in Ballygunge Escorts Service in Ballygunge Female Escorts in Ballygunge Independent Escorts in Ballygunge Gariahat Escorts Escorts in Gariahat Escorts Service in Gariahat Female Escorts in Gariahat Independent Escorts in Gariahat Baguiati Escorts Escorts in Baguiati Escorts Service in Baguiati Female Escorts in Baguiati Independent Escorts in Baguiati Kaikhali Escorts Escorts in Kaikhali Escorts Service in Kaikhali Female Escorts in Kaikhali Independent Escorts in Kaikhali Naihati Escorts Escorts in Naihati Escorts Service in Naihati Female Escorts in Naihati Independent Escorts in Naihati Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Kolkata Escorts Gurgaon Escorts
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint